The published sources name Sukezane of the Fukuoka school as one of the smiths who represent the peak flourishing of that school in the mid period, and they place him beside the celebrated National Treasure "Nikkō Sukezane", the favored sword of Tokugawa Ieyasu, as the archetype of his hand. Tradition holds, the descriptions record, that he later moved to in at the order of the shogunate, together with Saburō Kunimune and Kunitsuna of Yamashiro; his name appears in the -smith genealogy of the Kanchiin-bon Meizukushi, and from old times the appellation " " has been applied to this line. One of the published descriptions goes further and calls him a forerunner of the smiths, so that he stands at the point where turns toward Sōshū.
The characterization the sources return to, blade after blade, sets him within a trio and then apart from it. When one names the representative Ichimonji makers of this era, the published descriptions write, one names Yoshifusa, Norifusa, and this Sukezane; all of them develop a flamboyant chōji-midare3. Sukezane, however, shows a ji and ha that are, in the recurring formula, distinctly stronger than those of the other smiths4, so that even amid their brilliance his work overflows with a sense of power5. The mark the sources single out as his own is the nie of the hardened edge: especially in the yakiba, they write, fine ko-nie adheres well6, revealing a manner unique to this smith.
The forging the descriptions assign to him is an itame-hada mixed with mokume, the grain standing in places (hada-dachi), with ji-nie thickly applied and chikei entering, over which a midare-utsuri rises vividly. On that jigane he tempers an exuberant chōji-midare mixed with gunome, carrying large-cluster ōbusa-chōji, jūka-chōji, and the tadpole-headed kawazu-ko chōji, the yaki-height rising and falling so that the temper is flamboyantly animated; ashi and yō enter freely, the nioiguchi is deep, and ko-nie adheres. What the sources record as the consistent measure of his hand is the activity that fills the edge: kinsuji and sunagashi run vigorously, with nie-suji mixed in, and the bōshi runs midare-komi, often turning to a point or to hakikake, at times taking on a flame-like form. Where it does not point it settles to a quiet ko-maru, the two readings of one restless hand.
The descriptions divide his work into two registers, read from the nakago and the mei together. Blades whose signature is cut high and toward the mune with a slightly finer, sharper chisel tend, they write, to a wide mihaba and a large-pattern chōji-midare with conspicuous rises and falls and deep nioi, and are the most quintessentially Sukezane in manner; blades whose signature is cut lower and toward the center with a thicker, rounded chisel run to a standard or slightly slender, gentle tachi form with the chōji worked smaller. The sources note an outlier to both: a slender, elegant tachi, suguha-based with ko-midare, ko-chōji, and ko-gunome, vigorous sunagashi and frequent kinsuji, which differs from his usual flamboyant chōji-midare and, at a glance, recalls the Ko-Bizen school. They prize it as documentary material for the breadth of his range. Most of his surviving great blades are ō-suriage and mumei, attributed by the Hon'ami and at times carrying their gold-inlay appraisals; where he signed, it is the two-character mei 助真.
From the rest of the Fukuoka Ichimonji the sources tell him by the deeper, more active nie, by the kinsuji and sunagashi that thread the edge, and by the pointed, hakikakebōshi. Toward Sagami they read the same forcefulness forward: one of the published descriptions, weighing a blade thick in ji-nie and rich in kinsuji and sunagashi, finds in it a Sōshū-den coloration7 and says it convincingly explains why the term "KamakuraIchimonji" came into use. It is by his Bizenchōji base and the bright midare-utsuri, which the Sagami work to come would lose, that he remains an Ichimonji master even as his power points beyond the school.
He is Sai-jō saku in Fujishiro's grading, and the weight of designation behind his name is heavy: two of his blades are National Treasures and eight are Important Cultural Properties, with twelve Tokubetsu Jūyō and fourteen Jūyō beneath them, some twenty-six blades standing in the Tokubetsu Jūyō and Jūyō tiers together. Almost all that survives is ō-suriagemumei attribution accepted as his work; signed pieces run to roughly half the corpus, and every reliable mei is the two characters the sources make a point of recognition. The provenance recorded against his blades runs through the men who held the country: Taikō Hideyoshi, Katō Kiyomasa, Tokugawa Ieyasu, and Tokugawa Tsunayoshi the fifth shogun, with the Owari Tokugawa Family, the Kishū Tokugawa Family, the Uesugi Family, the Chōfu Mōri Family, the Ikeda Family, the Ōkubo Family lords of Odawara, the Okudaira Family, and Hachisuka Tadataka. His finest are kept now in the Tokyo National Museum, the Tokugawa Art Museum, the Mitsui Memorial Museum, the Hayashibara Museum of Art, and Itsukushima Jinja, and only a small number can ever trade; but because some twenty-six blades stand across the Tokubetsu Jūyō and Jūyō tiers, a Sukezane does, with patience, come within reach of the serious collector, the most powerful of the Ichimonji hands.
Historical importance
Where Sukezane stands among comparable artisans: across all of nihontō, and within tradition, era, and period. The tiers (Foremost · Leading · Major · Notable) weigh official designations from the NBTHK and Japan's Agency for Cultural Affairs, together with historical honors of lasting repute such as the Sansaku and Meibutsu-chō.