NihontoWatch MonNihontoWatchBETA
MarketEncyclopedia
NihontoWatch Mon

NihontoWatchBETA

Market
Encyclopedia
Overview·Kantei·Designations·Provenance·Blade Forms·Signatures·Lineage·School
OverviewKanteiDesignationsProvenanceBlade FormsSignaturesLineageSchool
  1. Schools
  2. Aoe
  3. Ko-Aoe
  4. Toshitsugu

Aoe Toshitsugu

俊次

Tokujū
Vol. 13, No. 42 · Tachi

Aoe Toshitsugu

俊次

6 ranked works

ProvinceBitchuEraKenryaku (1211–1213)PeriodKamakuraSchoolAoeTraditionBizen-denFujishiroJo-jo sakuToko Taikan1,800(top 3%)TypeSwordsmithCodeTOS227
1Jūyō Bunkazai
1Jūyō Bijutsuhin
2Tokubetsu Jūyō2Jūyō Tōken

Overview

Toshitsugu is a smith of Bicchū, working in the early period and transmitted in the reference works as a son either of Moritsugu or of Tsuguiye, with the placing his activity about the Kenryaku era. The school grew up in the iron country of the lower Takahashi river, around the villages of and Manju, and the published sources reserve the name for the work of the school that does not descend later than roughly the middle of the period. Within that early body Toshitsugu stands as one of the names by which the manner is recognized, though the published commentary returns again and again to a single fact about him: that his signed work scarcely survives. The states plainly that of this smith "extant signed works are exceedingly few" (現存する有銘作は僅少である), and it is against that scarcity that each surviving blade is weighed.

His characteristic hand is the , several still bearing a bold two-character signature cut on the , one of them with high and a small , the rest shortened yet keeping the old carriage with marked , one running to an -leaning point. Over the steel he sets a deliberately quiet temper. The base is a or a plain into which , and small enter, and coming in well, the deep in with thick , and running through it. It is not the flamboyant clove-flower of the great schools but a calm irregular line, and on one broad late a breaks the temper near the while the turns bright and clear. The runs straight to a small , and on the finest signed turns back from into a fuller sweep.

The is where the school speaks. Toshitsugu forges a , in places an mixed with that flows and stands a little, with adhering and entering, and through it run the patchy and the crepe-like surface the published sources name a , calling the texture in so many words a "crepe-like grain" (縮緬状の肌合). A faint stands over that on his signed pieces. On his most refined attributed work the reflection becomes his particular note: a suji- gathers near the edge while a rises toward the back, and the two together give the layered, stepped that sets those blades apart. The published sources read the whole of this manner as quieter than the work of the day, "somewhat more subdued, with an astringent depth of flavor when compared with contemporary " (同時代の備前物に比べると幾分地味で渋い味わい).

His record divides into two faces. The first is the signed already described, the foundation of any judgment of his hand. The second is the gold-inlaid Kōfū, broad in body with little taper from base to tip, thick in , deeply curved, ending in a compact , the standing overall with minute and the suji- and that read as . Because that powerful shape and those features bind it so closely to the signed of the thirteenth session, the published sources judge it the work of the smith. The file marks on the tang are a large , named a point of appreciation for the school, and the commentary notes that many smiths, Toshitsugu among them, cut the signature on the rather than the customary , calling the "large file marks a point of appreciation for this group" (大筋違の鑢目はこの派の見どころ).

What separates Toshitsugu within his own province is exactly this calm. Where the wider stream and the schools beyond it carry a showier , his hand keeps to the -based over the , the astringent register the judges treat as the old Bicchu taste. The thirteenth-session is held up not merely as a good Toshitsugu but as a high point of the school as a whole, the naming it "an outstanding piece not only among this smith's works but within the group itself" (同工のみならず同派の中でも出色の一口); of an earlier the body of commentary says that a piece of such quality "has no equal elsewhere" (他に類を見ない) among his surviving signed work. His standing rests less on volume than on the height of the few that remain.

For the collector Toshitsugu is a rare early name carried at a high rank. Fujishiro grades him Jō-jō . He has no National Treasures; his record runs instead through an Important Cultural Property, a held at Dazaifu Tenmangū in Fukuoka, a prewar Jūyō Bijutsuhin now in the Sano Art Museum in Shizuoka, two and a small number of , six designated works in all on the official record. The signed pieces are the precious ones, the published sources prizing the for keeping its original tang and signature; the , secured to him by its bond to the signed , is the other way his hand reaches a collection. With only a handful of blades across the and tiers, and most of them held rather than traded, a signed Toshitsugu comes to light only seldom; a privately held example is a notable thing for a collector to encounter, and a document of how quietly, and how well, the old Bicchu smiths worked beside the brighter forges of .

Kantei

one quiet Ko-Aoe hand seen in two records: the signed tachi with its chu-suguha and ko-midare over a chirimen-like ji of jifu and faint utsuri, and the o-suriage mumei katana gold-inlaid Kofu attributed to him by the same ji, the same suguha-based ko-midare, and the layered suji- and midare-utsuri the sources read as dan-utsuri; framed by the scholarship that Ko-Aoe is more subdued and astringent than contemporary Bizen

Toshitsugu is a smith of Bicchu, transmitted as a son either of Moritsugu or of Tsuguiye, the reference works placing him about the Kenryaku era of the early period; extant signed works are very few, so his record is among the slighter of the names yet stands at a high rank. His recognized hand is the , several still in original tang and signed with the two-character on the , others , slender to broad with high , a or compact . Over a mixed with that stands a little, with , and the patchy the published sources call a -like ground, he sets a quiet temper: a or base into which , and small enter, and well in, the deep, thick, and running through, the straight to a or an -like turnback. The reflection is his particular note: a suji- near the edge with toward the back giving the layered seen on his finest . The gold-inlaid Kofu is attributed to him by exactly this and and tied to his signed .

Diagnostic discriminators

unique vs contemporary Bizen baseline (no chirimen jifu ground)

unique vs his signed tachi (a single faint utsuri)

his hand is a chu-suguha or suguha base carrying ko-midare, ko-choji and small gunome, not the flamboyant choji-midare of the wider Aoe; the published sources read this calm as the old Bicchu manner, more subdued than the Bizen work of the day

unique vs Bizen baseline (katte-sagari / kiri yasurime)

Observation by phase

The signed tachi (his recognized hand)

His representative record is the , several signed with a bold two-character cut on the , one still with high and a , others yet keeping the old shape with marked , one of character. The ground is a , in places an mixed with that flows and stands a little, with , and the patchy the published sources name a -like ground; a faint stands. Over it the temper is deliberately calm: a or base into which , and small enter, and frequent, the deep and well adhered, and running through, the at times subdued, at times bright and clear, with near the on one piece. The runs straight to a , on one broad turning back from into an -like form. The file marks are a large , named a point of appreciation for the school, and the published sources note that many smiths sign on the . On the 13th-session they call the workmanship outstanding not only among Toshitsugu's works but within the group as a whole.

Sugata 姿
Jigane 地鉄
Hamon 刃文
Bōshi 帽子

The o-suriage mumei katana (attributed Ko-Aoe, gold-inlaid Kofu)

The other face of his record is the attributed to him and gold-inlaid Kofu, somewhat wide in body with little taper from base to tip, a thick , deep and a compact . The ground is an mixed with , the grain standing overall, with adhering thickly and minutely, fine and patchy . The reflection is the tell here: a suji- near the edge and a toward the back, together giving the layered . The temper is again a base, chiefly , with a faint flavor and a little , and entering, the deep, thick, and , the subdued. The runs straight with a shallow , finishing -like with . The published sources affirm this as work from the and , and because its powerful shape and these features bind it so strongly to Toshitsugu's signed , judge it the work of the smith; they praise its ample and sound and .

Jigane 地鉄
Hamon 刃文
Bōshi 帽子
Scholarship

The published sources record that Toshitsugu is transmitted as a son either of Ko-Aoe Moritsugu or of Tsuguiye, that the Meikan places his active period about the Kenryaku era, and that extant signed works are exceedingly few. They describe the Ko-Aoe manner, his included, as a forging in which mokume stands out and the grain tends to rise, producing the chirimen-like texture with much jifu, the hamon a gentle suguha tone or one mixing small irregularity, always well covered in nie, and on the whole more subdued and astringent than the Bizen work of the same period.

On the o-suriage mumei katana gold-inlaid Kofu the published sources affirm Ko-Aoe from the ji and ha, and because its broad, deeply curved shape with compact chu-kissaki and its layered suji- and midare-utsuri bind it so strongly to Toshitsugu's signed Tokubetsu Juyo tachi, judge it the work of the same smith, praising its deep nioi, thick ko-nie, abundant ashi, yo, kinsuji and sunagashi, and its ample hiraniku with sound ji and ha.

Designations

Kokuhō—
Jūyō Bunkazai1
Jūyō Bijutsuhin1
Gyobutsu—
Tokubetsu Jūyō2
Jūyō Tōken2

Elite Standing

0.23 across 6 designated works

Top 10% among smiths

Provenance

1 documented provenance across certified works by Toshitsugu

Provenance Standing

0 works held in elite collections across 1 documented provenances

Top 52% among smiths

Raw score: 1.97 / 10

Blade Forms

Distribution across 6 ranked works

Signatures

Signature types across 6 ranked works

Currently Available

Lineage

Toshitsugu
Students (5)
  1. 1.Suketsugu助次15designated
  2. 2.Shigetsugu重次5designated
  3. 3.Toshikatsu利勝
  4. 4.Tsuguyori次依1designated
  5. 5.Yukitsugu行次

Aoe School

Other artisans of the Aoe school

  1. 1.Tsugunao次直27designated
  2. 2.Yasutsugu康次11designated
  3. 3.Naotsugu直次15designated
  4. 4.Tsunetsugu恒次13designated
  5. 5.Kanetsugu包次9designated
  6. 6.Yoshitsugu吉次1 for sale17designated
  7. 7.Suketsugu助次15designated
  8. 8.Moritsugu守次9designated
  9. 9.Masatsune正恒16designated
  10. 10.Tametsugu爲次6designated
  11. 11.Moritoshi守利9designated
  12. 12.Tsuguyoshi次吉16designated