NihontoWatch MonNihontoWatchBETA
MarketEncyclopedia
NihontoWatch Mon

NihontoWatchBETA

Market
Encyclopedia
Overview·Kantei·Designations·Provenance·Blade Forms·Signatures·School
OverviewKanteiDesignationsProvenanceBlade FormsSignaturesSchool
  1. Schools
  2. Aoe
  3. Sue-Aoe
  4. Tsugunao

Aoe Tsugunao

次直

Tokujū
Vol. 15, No. 27 · Tachi

Aoe Tsugunao

次直

27 ranked works

ProvinceBitchuEraTeiwa (1345–1350)PeriodNanbokuchōSchoolAoeTraditionBizen-denFujishiroJo-jo sakuToko Taikan1,200(top 5%)TypeSwordsmithCodeTSU82
3Jūyō Bunkazai
5Jūyō Bijutsuhin
7Tokubetsu Jūyō12Jūyō Tōken

Overview

Tsugunao of stands with Tsuguyoshi and Moritsugu as a representative master of the school in the mid period, and his record is unusually legible for that age: the published sources list extant dated works through the Jowa, 'o, Shohei, Bunna and Enbun eras (1345 to 1361), the center of his activity falling around Bunna and Enbun, and most pieces carry the long signature no ju Tsugunao (備中国住次直作) with the date cut on the reverse. The prewar designation record adds that this Tsugunao is said to have been a son of Yoshitsugu. Behind him the school divides in two. work, up to about the mid period, is generally -based with a subdued and a large, standing ; from the end of the manner changes, and by the period the published sources describe work that is -based, with a vividly clear over a tightly packed . Tsugunao belongs wholly to this later, clear-tempered , the line the sources call , and he stands near its close.

The published sources state his work in a single recurring formula: two manners, one a flamboyant -, the other a with a tightened , both -based and both executed at a high level. The first is the celebrated hand. One designation text speaks of "the - that may be called Tsugunao's family art" (お家芸), and another judges that this manner, its tight and so bright and clear, "was, within the period, the sole domain of this school" (独壇場) and its emblematic territory. In these blades and enter the frequently, the temper is -dominant with , fine and run through it, and the comes in , thrusts up, points and returns deeply. At its most flamboyant the can even leave the slant behind: an Enbun 6 , its lively in variation and rise and fall, is described as "a truly florid workmanship that recalls the Fukuoka ", the single such comparison in his record.

The beneath both manners is the school's own. Some blades retain what the published sources call the 's original , but most show a tightly packed mixed with , adhering thickly in fine particles, the peculiar mottled the sources name , and clear patches of emerging here and there. On the finest pieces the reflection doubles: a stands toward the while a straight band rises along the , together forming what the texts call . The second manner rests on this steel. It is a , at times shading into shallow , mixed with and , slanting here and there so that and enter even within the straight line; the is tight, bright and clear, and on a dated Shohei 7 the sources note the fine . Famed though he is for the slanted , the designation texts repeat that "even when he tempers he is skillful, and shows high technique", and one in is praised for a so crisply tightened and bright that it imparts a serene, restrained taste. Whichever manner he works, the sources observe, the thrusts up with a pointed tip, a school tell that survives both hands.

The two manners divide largely by form. Of his records nearly all, eleven of twelve, run to , whether or , while the flamboyant - is carried by the blades, the and of wide , thin and shallow that wear the typical silhouette, and by . His signing habits are themselves a study: the long with the date written down in one line, the , is noted as not rare in the of this period, as is the rounded construction; the southern court year Shohei 7 appears beside the northern Bunna and Enbun dates; and where most long blades of the period were later shortened into , his record preserves signed and dated , among them an blade of 89.8 centimeters dated Jowa 3. carry attributions to Tsugunao by the Honami, Mitsutada or Kotsune, which the upholds. The boundary of the name is drawn from the work itself: a in -dominant , unlike the -led temper of the Enbun-dated pieces, is read in Honma's recorded comment as "possibly later than the works with Enbun dates", and a is judged "probably a little later in date than the Enbun-dated works of Tsugunao", so the published record itself holds open the question of a later generation under the name.

Within the school the manners divide between the masters: Tsugunao left more - and Tsuguyoshi more , and the sources write that "in this point he may be said to stand in contrast to Tsuguyoshi". What marks a blade as his are his own documented features in combination: the slanting set of the and , the tight bright over a -based , the and mottling in the packed , the stepped on the finest work, and the thrusting, pointed . He stands at the close of the line the sources call ; no individual pupil is named in his record, but the blades judged later than his Enbun-dated work show the Tsugunao name carrying on past the prime master.

Fujishiro grades him Jo-jo , and twenty-seven designated works stand on record: three Important Cultural Properties, five Bijutsuhin, seven and twelve . The provenance behind them runs through the great houses. The Maeda of held his Enbun 5 as a treasure of the house, styled the Dai- (大青江) after the famous pair of ; a dated formerly of the Yanagisawa is documented by the note on its old scabbard as the shogun Tsunayoshi's gift on his first visit to the Yanagisawa mansion in Genroku 4; a dated descended in the Choshu Mori, a bears Mori Motoyasu's possession inscription in gold inlay beside the record of 's shortening, another was transmitted in the Kishu Tokugawa house, and one is accompanied by a letter of commendation of Tokugawa Hidetada together with its period . The Important Cultural Property blades are patrimony, held by the Tokyo National Museum, the Tokugawa Art Museum and the , and the Hayashibara Museum of Art holds one of the Bijutsuhin. For the private collector the realistic field is the nineteen blades of the and tiers, most of recorded whereabouts in private hands; these are held rather than traded, and a signed, dated Tsugunao, of a kind the published sources themselves call rare among the survivors of this school and period, comes to market only seldom and is an occasion when it does.

Kantei

2 style manners (flamboyant saka-choji vs tight-nioiguchi suguha) x form (hira-zukuri ko-wakizashi / tanto / naginata-naoshi lean choji; tachi lean suguha, 11 of 12 records), set against the sue-Aoe school formula (nioi-deki, bright tight nioiguchi, packed ko-itame with jifu and sumi-hada, pointed tsukiage boshi), plus a later-generation question after Enbun

Tsugunao is, with Tsuguyoshi and Moritsugu, the representative master of the school in the mid . Dated work runs Jowa through Enbun (1345 to 1361), centered on Bunna-Enbun, and most pieces carry the long signature ' no ju Tsugunao ' with a date. The sources state his work in one formula: a flamboyant - hand, for which he holds a settled repute as the master of -, and a tight- hand, both -based, bright and clear. The is tightly packed mixed with the school's peculiar () and clear patches, at times forming the stepped ; the tends to thrust up and point. A -led and a judged later than the Enbun-dated works raise a later-generation question.

Diagnostic discriminators

52% of his works · 3.7× vs Kanemitsu (Osafune)

42% of his works

45% of his works · 1.9× vs Nagamitsu (Osafune)

10% of his works

Observation by phase

The flamboyant saka-choji manner (his celebrated hand)

hira-zukuri sunnobi ko-wakizashi and tanto, naginata-naoshi, and Honami-attributed mumei katana (choji-midare on 4 of 8 wakizashi records, while 11 of 12 tachi run suguha)

- with and entering thickly, -dominant with , fine and , the whole bright and clear; the an standing somewhat, with and the conspicuous patches. The runs in , thrusts up, points, and returns deep. The sources call this his family art and say that in the this tight, bright - was the sole domain of the school. At its most flamboyant the can leave the slant behind: one is likened to the Fukuoka , the single such comparison in his record.

Sugata 姿
Jigane 地鉄
Hamon 刃文
Bōshi 帽子

The tight-nioiguchi suguha manner

tachi above all (suguha on 11 of 12 tachi records, chu-suguha and hoso-suguha, the dated tachi running Jowa to Enbun)

, at times shading to shallow , with and mixed in, here and there slanting, and entering even inside the straight line, in one masterpiece the fine ; the tight, bright and clear. The is , tightly packed, fine and thick, appearing with the , and on the finest pieces the stepped stands. The runs with a thrusting-up feel, the tip or faintly pointed. The sources repeat that, famed though he is for -, his too is skilled work of high technique.

Sugata 姿
Jigane 地鉄
Hamon 刃文
Bōshi 帽子

Gunome-led and post-Enbun outliers: the later-generation question

less firmly establishedundated or stylistically divergent tachi (gunome-dominant, or hoso-suguha placed later than the Enbun-dated works)

Two blades draw the boundary of the name from the work itself. A in -dominant , unlike the -led of the Enbun-dated pieces, is read by the sources as possibly the work of a later generation; and a with tight is placed a little later in date than the Enbun-dated works. The label 'late' here is the judges' own inference from style, so this group is held at medium confidence: the Tsugunao name appears to have carried past the prime master.

Hamon 刃文
Scholarship

Extant dated works run Jowa, Kan'o, Shohei, Bunna and Enbun (1345 to 1361), the center of activity at Bunna-Enbun; Shohei, the southern court era, appears beside the northern years.

Kakikudashi signatures, the long mei and the date run down in one line on the same side, are noted as not rare in the Aoe of this period, as is the rounded maru-mune build.

O-suriage mumei blades carry kinzogan attributions to Tsugunao by the Honami, Mitsutada or Kotsune, which the NBTHK upholds.

A gunome-dominant tachi differing from the choji-led hamon of the Enbun-dated work is read, in Honma's note, as possibly by a later generation, the seed of the Tsugunao generation question.

Designations

Kokuhō—
Jūyō Bunkazai3
Jūyō Bijutsuhin5
Gyobutsu—
Tokubetsu Jūyō7
Jūyō Tōken12

Elite Standing

0.84 across 27 designated works

Top 3% among smiths

Provenance

13 documented provenances across certified works by Tsugunao

Provenance Standing

9 works held in elite collections across 13 documented provenances

Top 7% among smiths

Raw score: 2.75 / 10

Blade Forms

Distribution across 27 ranked works

Signatures

Signature types across 27 ranked works

Currently Available

Aoe School

Other artisans of the Aoe school

  1. 1.Yasutsugu康次11designated
  2. 2.Naotsugu直次15designated
  3. 3.Tsunetsugu恒次13designated
  4. 4.Kanetsugu包次9designated
  5. 5.Yoshitsugu吉次1 for sale17designated
  6. 6.Suketsugu助次15designated
  7. 7.Moritsugu守次9designated
  8. 8.Masatsune正恒16designated
  9. 9.Tametsugu爲次6designated
  10. 10.Toshitsugu俊次6designated
  11. 11.Moritoshi守利9designated
  12. 12.Tsuguyoshi次吉16designated